Monday, May 12, 2025
Home Blog Page 55

Spain issued over 25,000 gold visas

Spain also remains one of the most popular golden visa scheme in europe along with Portugal and Greece.  Spain was ranked as the 3rd best golden visa scheme in BCI golden visa rankings for 2019 for having the sixth best citizenship in the world.

 

The Spanish golden visa scheme cannot be underestimated, according to the latest figures released, Spain has issued 25,830 gold visas all over spain and some 11% of these gold visas went to property investment in Spain above EUR 500,000.

 

Gold visas issued in Spain

 

The Golden visa investment through real estate slightly increased by 4% in 2018, compared to the previous year reaching its peak in 2015 and 2016.  The 2018 levels are still down compared to 2015/16

 

Golden visa spain
Gold visas issued for property investment from Jan 1,  2013 to March 31, 2019

 

Over 6000 chinese and 2000 russians have received golden visas in Spain according to the figures.

 

In 2018, Chinese investment in spanish golden visa scheme have increased from 362 to 409 (12%), while Russian interest have declined consistently from 2015.  In 2018 only 47 gold visas have been issued to Russians for buying property compared to 70 previous year

 

Chinese and Russians
Golden visas issued to Chinese and Russians from 2013 to 2019

 

Spain issues golden visa for various categories including property investment of EUR 500,000 or more

 

  • Public debt (€2 million)
  • Shares (€ 1 million)
  • Investment funds or venture capital funds set up in Spain (€1 million)
  • Bank deposits (€500,000)
  • Real estate (€500,000)

 

Investors qualify for visa (1 year) when applying outside Spain (Spanish embassy) or will be issued residence permit for 2 years when applying in Spain with a path to apply for spanish citizenship after 10 years (quicker for certain cases).

 

Spain has one of the best and powerful passports in the world.

 

Spain golden visa statistics
Source: leconomic.cat

 

Montenegro selects SRM and Exiger for CIP Due diligence

The Montenegro government has announced the decision of selection of Due diligence firms for the Citizenship by investment program (CIP).

By reviewing the submitted applications, the Secretariat for Development Projects assessed that applications that met the requirements of that Decision and the Public Invitation, the applications were received from the following applicants:

 

  • S-RM Intelligence and Risk Consulting LTD, UK
  •  EXIGER CANADA INC, CANADA

 

The Secretariat for Development Projects published a Public Call for the selection of agents for the assessment of international suitability number ED – 2/74 dated 04.03.2019. and Amendments to the Public Call for the selection of agents for the assessment of international suitability number ED – 2/104 of 15.03.2019. year .

 

The following firms submitted  11 timely applications were submitted, among them only two DD firms were selected for vetting of applicants

 

  • REFINITIV LIMITED, UK
  • BISHOPS SERVICES LLC, USA
  • PKF Savvides & Co. Limited, Cyprus
  • Harod Assocciates Limited, UK
  • S-RM Intelligence and Risk Consulting LTD, UK
  • ARTEMON DOO, MONTENEGRO
  • BDO USA LLP, USA
  • CORPORATE RESOLUTIONS INC, USA
  • MICUNOVIC AND PARTNERS OAD, MONTENEGRO
  • EXIGER CANADA INC, CANADA
  • GLOBAL SOURCE CONSULTING, CYPRUS

 

The official announcement from the secretariat of development projects is here

This Golden visa is the granddaddy of all schemes

The Hong Kong government launched Capital Investment Entrant Scheme (CIES) in October 2003. The scheme required investors to invest HK$10 million (USD 1.25m) in permissible investment asset classes such as equities, bonds, debt securities etc.

 

This scheme was suspended from 15 January 2015 until further notice.

 

Although this scheme is no more today, during the period of 12 years, 3 months,  this scheme collected a whopping HK $313 billion (US$39b), becoming the granddaddy of golden visa schemes, eclipsing all other golden visa schemes in world.  Even the US EB-5 despite running for 27 years since 1992, collected only $36 billion. Portugal received close to $5 billion dollars from golden visa investments.

 

Golden visa investment total
The Big Six Golden Visa schemes

 

Here is the quick statistics of economic impact created by HK capital investment scheme

 

  • HK$42 billion invested in real estate, $270m in financial assets
  • Over 44,000 applications received, 35,000 applications approved
  • 91% of rich Chinese applied for this scheme, foreign nationals only 8%

 

Source: HK Immigration Dept

 

Here is the breakdown of the statistics of applicants under CIES, as at 31-12-2018, according to the latest statistics provided by HK immigration office.

Received Approval-in-principle granted Formal Approval granted
Foreign nationals 3 088 25 2 183
Macao SAR residents 538 5 430
Chinese nationals with permanent residence overseas 40 478 605 32 125
Stateless persons with permanent residence in a foreign country 3 0 3
Taiwan residents 546 3 376
Total 44 653 638 35 117

 

Breakdown of Investment Classes in Formal Approval Cases (as at 31-12-2018)

 

Real Estate (Million) Specified Financial Assets (Million) Total (Million)
42,588.23 270,833.35 313,421.58

 

From 14 October 2010, as a part of changes to the scheme the investment threshold (and Net assets or Net equity requirement) has been raised from HK$6.5 million to HK$10 million and real estate has been suspended as a class of permissible investment assets.

 

The entrepreneur route for Hong Kong is still open for potential entrepreneurs and investors.

Portugal collected €167m in golden visa fees

Portugal golden visa scheme being the most popular visa scheme in the world, has been the be biggest revenue earner in terms of fees.

 

In addition to €4.4 billion euros, the scheme  earned more than €167 million euros state fee with the issuance and renewal of residence permits, since the scheme launched in 2012, according to a report published by portuguese daily Dinheirovivo.pt.

 

Since 2012, more than 19,000 ARI residence permits SEF  issued with more than 17,000 extensions for investors and family members.

 

 

The costs for each visa issue are currently €5,324.6 euros, to which is added a fee for the analysis of the application in the amount of € 532.7 euros and renewals cost € 2,662.3, plus the same rate.

 

Over 90% of the investments in Portugal went into real estate activity for golden visa permits by foreigners.

 

Golden visa statistics
Golden visas issued from Oct 2012 to March 2019, according to SEF

 

Chinese are the biggest investors in Portuguese gold visa scheme, followed by Brazilians and Turks. Brazil has a special relationship with Portugal and both countries have visa waiver agreement.

 

Chinese in Portugal
Investor status as of March 2019 – Source: SEF

 

Golden visa fees

These are the fee charged by SEF for residence permits under ARI/investment activity:

Receipt and analysis of the application for the granting or renewal of a residence permit for investment activity, in accordance with Article 90a of Law 23/2007, of July 4; € 532.70
Issuance of a residence permit for the investment activity, in accordance with article 90-A of Law no. 23/2007, of July 4; € 5324,60
Renewal of a residence permit for the investment activity, pursuant to article 90-A of Law no. 23/2007, of July 4; € 2662,30
Residence permit for family reunited with the holders of residence permits for investment activity, in accordance with article 90-A of Law no. 23/2007, of July 4; € 5324,60
renewal of a residence permit for family members reunited with the holders of residence permits for investment activity, pursuant to article 90-A of Law no. 23/2007, of July 4; € 2662,30
issuance of a duplicate of the residence permit for the investment activity – 50% of the value of the fee provided for in item 1; € 266.40
issuance of a third and successive residence permit for the investment activity – 100% of the value of the fee provided for in item 1; € 532.70
replacement of the residence permit for the investment activity, by changing the elements € 133,30

 

Moldova citizenship becomes more valuable with Belt road initiative

Moldova is set to benefit from Belt road initiative with two major roads (300km)  at an estimated cost of $400m built by major chinese firms.  One road will encircle capital Chisinau and the other will connect Ukraine in the north. Moldova to benefit from two major roads increased trade, bringing economic growth and large scale foreign investment inflows through the BRI.

 

China’s Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) is the biggest and most ambitious 21st century silk road  connecting Asia with Africa and Europe via land and maritime networks along six corridors with the aim of improving regional integration, increasing trade and stimulating economic growth covering over 70 countries, accounting for about 65 per cent of the world’s population and around one-third of the world’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP).

 

The name was coined in 2013 by China’s President Xi Jinping, who drew inspiration from the concept of the Silk Road established during the Han Dynasty 2,000 years ago – an ancient network of trade routes that connected China to the Mediterranean via Eurasia for centuries. The BRI has also been referred to in the past as ‘One Belt One Road’.

 

BRI China
Source/Credit: Forbes

 

The BRI comprises a Silk Road Economic Belt – a trans-continental passage that links China with south east Asia, south Asia, Central Asia, Russia and Europe by land – and a 21st century Maritime Silk Road, a sea route connecting China’s coastal regions with south east and south Asia, the South Pacific, the Middle East and Eastern Africa, all the way to Europe.  BRI is expected to involve over US$1 trillion in investments, largely in infrastructure development for ports, roads, railways and airports, as well as power plants and telecommunications networks. China has signed co-operational document on the belt and road initiative with 126 countries and 29 international organisations

 

Moldova is expected to be a major trade hub in the region with two major belt roads passing through the country carrying millions of dollars worth of supplies, logistics, oil through Moldova. With significant growth in Moldova on the horizon, citizenship in the country also becomes valuable.  Real estate and construction also expected to gain significant growth from BRI.

 

Moldova currently offers fast track citizenship for investment program suitable for investors, requiring one time contribution of EUR 100,000 to government fund, EUR 250,000 investment in real estate or government debt (treasury bonds).  All qualifying family members and investors qualify for passport and citizenship can be passed through future generations without interruptions through investment scheme.

 

Italy, Greece also set to benefit from the BRI initiative.

 

As of 26 March 2019, Moldovan citizens had visa-free or visa on arrival access to121 countries and territories, ranking the Moldovan passport 45th in terms of travel freedom (tied with the Micronesian passport) according to the Henley PassportIndex

 

Montenegro CIP pilot phase to be closely monitored

The much anticipated Montenegro special citizenship by investment is expected to open for first applications by end of 2019 and will be fully operational by 2020 according secretariat announcement last month. The fast track citizenship scheme requires EUR 250,000 investment + EUR 100,000 donation to fund for the development of Montenegro.

 

Minister of Sustainable Development and Tourism Pavle Radulović  addressed the importance of economic citizenship program during the third conference of honorary consuls.

 

“It will be available to maximum 2.000 most eminent applicants within the determined timeframe of three years. That represents an additional mechanism of protections, since the program is de facto introduced as “pilot” whose performances will be closely monitored during its implementation.”, he said

 

Minister Radulović stated that funds raised by this program will be directed to development projects that have to generate multiple benefits for the state – from economic activities in terms of investments, employment and better supply and competitiveness of overall economy.

 

The Minister has assured that every step of the citizenship process will be completely transparent.

 

From all those aspects it is clear that all mechanisms of management of that process is in the hands of the Government, while eligibility criteria in the proposed model are defined so that every step is completely transparent, which eliminates every potential manipulation, concluded Minister Radulović.

 

The Montenegrin CIP will only run for three years  from 1 January 2019 until 31 December 2021. During the period of the special program, up to 2000 decisions on the admission to Montenegrin citizenship on the basis of a special program may be adopted at maximum.

 

The Government has already announced 3 marketing agents and decision on selection of due diligence providers will be announced soon.

 

As a part of due diligence process, all CIP applicants will be first checked by the special mediation agents, then the international credentials agents and then auditors for source of income.  The final decision of citizenship is made by Ministry of Internal Affairs and National Security Agency.  Citizenship will be granted to most suitable applicants, who are willing to invest in the development of Montenegro.

 

The Montenegro government expected to raise EUR 200 million (from EUR 100,000 donations) and excess of EUR 250 million from 2000 applicants investing in the country. The money from donations will be allocated to the less-developed local self-government units and will be spent primarily on infrastructure and facilities northern areas of the country.

 

Montenegro is in a leading position on its path towards EU accession, compared to the other five aspirants from the Western Balkans. With most negotiation chapters open and Montenegro expected to meet the 2025 accession date suggested by the European Commission’s new 2018 enlargement strategy

Due diligence is at the heart of citizenship by investment

Mr. Peter S. Vincent, a former high-ranking civil servant at the United States Department of Homeland Security in an interview with Die Weltwoche talks about security, due diligence with citizenship by investment schemes. 

 

The citizenship by investment programs subject all applicants to multitiered due diligence at the initial stages and then, submit their applications to member state intelligence and law enforcement officials to conduct additional deep due diligence and intense vettings.

 

Mr. Vincent stated  The European Union is rightfully concerned about due diligence and vetting of all applicants for a citizenship in European Union member states, but it should be spending its scarce resources, time and energy on true threats.  As a counter-terrorism expert, my focus is always on the most effective and most efficient means of identifying true threats and leveraging scarce resources in a way that is targeting the greatest threats, he said.

 

Due diligence

 

Due diligence is already at the heart of the initial stage of an individual seeking citizenship by investment. That needs to be done at the initial stage by the agent or the broker of such services in order to determine whether or not those individuals are who they say they are and that their funds are completely legitimate. That due diligence and vetting needs to be conducted by a legitimate third-party due diligence providers to identify an individual in terms of establishing his or her true identity, as well as the source of provenance of all sources of income that they’re relying on. Then where there is any doubt whatsoever it must be resolved against the individual correctly or incorrectly and the agent or broker should not go forward if they cannot establish the identity and/or the source of all of their funds.

 

After the applicants cleared by brokers, The law enforcement and intelligence gathering services of that sovereign nation state must conduct its own robust due diligence of those applicants to include not only its own records but that of its partner countries across the globe, and also, providing that information to Interpol to ensure that the individual’s not on a wanted list, such as a red notice, as well as coordinating with the United States and its sanctions through the Office of Foreign Asset Control or the Financial Crimes Enforcement Network with the Department of Treasury to make sure that individuals are not seeking to avoid Iranian and North Korean sanctions.

 

Mr. Vincent warns about million people become naturalised Europeans every year – without proper checks being carried out.

 

Romania and Bulgaria

 

Mr. Vincent thinks Bulgaria and Romania are legitimate schengen beneficiaries.

 

Romania and Bulgaria have really robust intelligence agencies that are very skilled and experienced, given their history, but my concern is not that those agencies are in any way deficient.

 

My concern is that applications submitted by unscrupulous brokers don’t ever go through those agencies for vetting or due diligence, that they’re simply handed-off to a Government official authorized to grant citizenship and to issue passports with no initial third-party due diligence, let alone sovereign state intelligence and law enforcement agency checks.

I’ve seen reported that individuals are able to obtain legitimate passports in Romania or Bulgaria for as little as €5,000. Other reports suggest that individuals are able to purchase legitimate passports for €30,000.

 

Intelligence

 

The Five Eyes project with United States, Canada, New Zealand, Australia, and the United Kingdom have had historically a very robust, intelligent sharing agreement.

 

The European Union does a good job of sharing information amongst intelligence and law enforcement agencies.  Some countries, for historic reasons, are less willing to share intelligence with other countries, given a past history of war and conflict or a lack of trust in their fellow European member states.

 

Mr. Vincent stated, United Kingdom does actually leave the European Union, which is yet to be decided, then the European Union will, unfortunately, lose most, but not all, of the incredibly powerful intelligence that the United Kingdom’s MI6 and MI5 currently hold.

 

Mr. Vincent currently oversees the Government Advisory and Business Intelligence departments at Henley & Partners, the world’s leading agency for residence and citizenship planning.

 

Read the full interview here

Citizenship for Sephardic Jews

by World Passport Museum

 

There has been much of talk about spain and portugal easing citizenship rules for sephardic jews. Today we will quickly cover this topic  on who are they? where do they come from? and why is spain and portugal simplifying citizenship path to sephardic jews.

 

Following the defeat of the Kingdom of Israel in the 720s BCE and the Kingdom of Judah in 586 BCE, the Jewish people became dispersed throughout much of the Middle East and Africa. The Jewish population in ancient Israel also was severely reduced by the Jewish–Roman wars and by the later hostile policies of the Christian emperors, against non-Christians. Following the Crusades and Inquisition, Jews from around the world began emigrating in increasing numbers.

 

Historically, European Jews have been classified into two major groups:

  •  Ashkenazim, or “Germanics” (“Ashkenaz” meaning “Germany” in Medieval Hebrew), denoting their Central European base, and
  • Sephardim, or “Hispanics” (“Sefarad” meaning “Hispania” or “Iberia” in Hebrew), denoting their Spanish, Portuguese or North African base.

 

A third historic term Mizrahim, or “Easterners” (“Mizrach” being “East” in Hebrew) has been used to describe other non-European Jewish communities to the east, but its usage has changed both over time and relative to the location where it was used.

 

Sephardic Jews descended from the Jews who lived in the Iberian Peninsula in the late 15th century, immediately prior to the issuance of the Alhambra Decree of 1492 by order of the Catholic Monarchs in Spain, and the decree of 1496 in Portugal by order of King Manuel I.

 

Prior to 1492, substantial Jewish populations existed in most Spanish and Portuguese provinces.

 

The Alhambra Decree (also known as the Edict of Expulsion) was an edict issued on 31 March 1492, by the joint Catholic Monarchs of Spain (Isabella I of Castile and Ferdinand II of Aragon) ordering the expulsion/exile of jews who did not comply to religious conversion.

 

Five years later, Portugal’s King Manuel issued a decree  to appease Spanish monarchs to marry their daughter.  The decree blocked jews from leaving by blocking ports of exit.

 

Both the Spanish and Portuguese edicts ordered their respective Jewish residents to choose one of only three options:

 

  • to convert to Catholicism and therefore to be allowed to remain within the kingdom,
  • to remain Jewish and to be expelled by the stipulated deadline, or
  • to be summarily executed.

 

The purpose Alhambra Decree of 1492,  was to eliminate their influence on Spain’s large converso population not convert to Judaism.

 

As a result of the Alhambra decree and persecution in prior years, over 200,000 Jews converted to Catholicism and between 40,000 and 100,000 were expelled, an indeterminate number returning to Spain in the years following the expulsion. Many fled to Portugal, Turkey and other countries.

 

The 1492 expulsion from Spain by the Catholic Monarchs however, made the Sephardic Jews hide and disperse to France, Italy, England, the Netherlands, Scandinavia, parts of what is now northwestern Germany, and to other existing communities in Christian Europe, as well as to those within the Ottoman Empire, to the Maghreb in North Africa and smaller numbers to other areas of the Middle East, and eventually to the Americas in the early 17th century. – Source: wikipedia

 

Today, according to a genetic research published by American Journal of Human Genetics, genetic markers show that one in five of Spaniards have Sephardic Jews markers.

 

Spain and Portugal offer expedited path to citizenship and passport  to sephardic jews who could prove their ancestory.

 

Spain and Portugal Passports

 

Spain

 

In 2015 the Government of Spain passed Law 12/2015 of 24 June, whereby Sephardic Jews with a connection to Spain could obtain Spanish citizenship by naturalisation, without the residency requirement.

 

The scheme was further extended to October 2019.  As of March 2018, some 6,432 people had been granted Spanish citizenship under the sephardic citizenship law. In Spain the citizenship application fee is €100 euro

 

Portugal

 

In April 2013 The Portuguese government offered naturalization path to the descendants of Portuguese Sephardic Jews who were expelled from Portugal and Spain in the fifteenth century.  Applicants must prove of Sephardic community of Portuguese origin with ties to Portugal through surnames in the family tree.

 

As of Feb 2018, 12,000 applications were in process, and 1,800 applicants had been granted Portuguese citizenship in 2017.  The citizenship

 

Diaspora population

 

There are about 2,2 million sephardic jews  population worldwide roughly make up to 16% of world’s Jewish population, with majority of them living in Israel, France and United Kingdom

 

 

No dual citizenship for Indian OCI card holders

The Constitution of India does not allow holding Indian citizenship and a citizenship of a foreign country simultaneously including OCI card holders.

 

Overseas Citizenship of India (OCI) Scheme was introduced  for persons of indian origin by amending the Citizenship Act, 1955 in August 2005.  The Overseas Citizenship of India (OCI) is an immigration status permitting a foreign citizen of Indian origin to live and work in the Republic of India indefinitely. OCI is an immigration status, not a citizenship status.

 

The OCI was introduced in response to demands for dual citizenship by the Indian diaspora, particularly in developed countries such as North America,.

 

The Indian embassy in New york has clarified that holding an OCI card in no way entitles its holders to claim the status of dual citizenship. OCI holders cannot become dual citizens.

 

 

The OCI documents consist of OCI Registration Booklet and a Universal visa sticker. It is mandatory for registered OCIs to carry their passports which carry the Universal visa sticker for entry into / exit from India. All  Persons of Indian origin (PIO) card holders with valid PIO cards since 2015, had to convert their PIO card to OCI card.

 

A registered Overseas Citizen (Non Resident Indians)  of India is granted multiple entry, multi purpose, life-long visa for visiting India, he/she is exempted from registration with Foreign Regional Registration Office for any length of stay in India.

 

OCI costs: US $ 275 or equivalent in local currency for each  applicant. In case of application submitted in India, the fee is Rs.15,000/-

 

Renunciation

 

Indian can also renounce citizenship at missions abroad. A person ceases to be an overseas citizen of India under subsection (1), every minor child of that person registered as an overseas citizen of India, shall thereupon cease to be an overseas citizen of India.

 

A stateless person cannot apply for an OCI, but there is a risk of renouncing indian citizenship. An OCI holder can be considered stateless if they lose citizenship of the other country.

 

The only way for indians to legally become foreign national is to renounce indian citizenship.

 

The MEA website has a special page  here

Strong economic growth in Cyprus supported by Citizenship by Investment

The EU has published a paper on economic forecast on Cyprus for Spring 2019 and in its report said  Cyprus’ economic expansion is set to remain robust, driven by domestic demand, but risks are tilted to the downside. Inflation is forecasted to remain subdued and budget is expected to return to surplus with public debt to steadily decline from 2019 onwards.

 

Cyprus continues to enjoy a remarkable post-crisis rebound with real GDP growth of 3.9% in 2018.

 

Cyprus economic growth
Total investment forecasted to be on positive side from 2019 onwards.

 

The paper described investments in cyprus forecasted to be robust, with  overall economic activity coming from ongoing tourism-related projects. Half of all transactions in residential construction driven by foreign demand, supported by the Citizenship by Investment programme.

 

A major scale of investments arise from ship registrations.

 

The paper described tourism-linked services is clouded by the recent bankruptcies of several airlines servicing Cyprus, slowing global demand, fierce competition, and high Brexit related uncertainty (UK citizens account for more than a third of all tourists) and warns that heavy reliance on foreign funding also leaves Cyprus vulnerable to external developments.

 

Cyprus has already received excess over 6.6 billion euros through the citizenship investment scheme. From May 15th, the council of ministers implemented new measures were implemented strengthening the cypriot citizenship scheme which include requirement of schengen visa, increased holding of property for five years and addition donation of EUR 150,000 for the development of Cyprus. All applicants had to pass due diligence checks and have no criminal record

 

 

Cyprus remained the second best citizenship by investment scheme in Best citizenships rankings behind Malta. Currently Cyprus remains the most expensive citizenship schemes in the world requiring over 2 million euros.

 

 

You can read the paper here